Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more amigoingtodie's commentslogin

Insightful. Thank you.


You need to watch Person of Interest and Minority Report.


I watched POI. I also heard cops using ML to predict crime locations. I am trying to find and reuse some existing code for a different project.


Don't be surprised if those predictions are heavily biased against minorities and poor people. Do you care if they do?

It's a similar problem to using ML to give people credit scores.

If the training data includes a lot of minorities and poor people breaking laws / delinquent payments, then your ML will simply key on race/economic status as a predictor.

So you've built a system that simply targets those groups.

But you might object and say that this race/economic status targeting gives the highest accuracy! It was only learned in the training data, after all. You can make a great classifier that is extremely unfair.

So you have to realize there is a conflict here between accuracy and fairness. This means there is a conflict between observational data (training), and using that data to produce decisions/outcomes.

If you make decisions/outcomes that reinforce the training data, you do not give racial groups/low economic status people a chance to improve their lives.

That is extremely inhuman, predatory, and unfair.


All I want to predict is time periods/locations which are vulnerable. Nothing more than that.


Racism is morally wrong but not mathematically wrong. P(criminal|black) > P(criminal), but if you observe that someone has black skin and treat them poorly because of it, you've done a bad thing. It doesn't matter that you were just following Bayesian reasoning because you're still hurting someone on the basis of something they can't control.

Lady Justice doesn't wear a blindfold as a fashion accessory. Discarding information is a key factor in nearly every established system of justice / morality. Refusing to do so (i.e. "just" running a ML algorithm) places you directly at odds with society's hard-earned best practices.


> Lady Justice doesn't wear a blindfold as a fashion accessory

I never noticed that before. Thanks for pointing this out!


> All I want to predict is time periods/locations which are vulnerable.

Ok, and to what end?

I assume someone else will be consuming these predictions, else you wouldn't bother at all.

What are your customers/users going to do with these predictions?

Or is that simply not your responsibility; someone else's problem?


Take a look at crimereports.com. You might get lucky and find a good source on a per city or county basis, it's too fragmented overall too try this. Different countries might have different documentation standards and publishing guidelines for this kinda of data, might be worth a shot to look.


and Psychopass


You don't sound glad about anything.


It is 65% of outdoor cameras operated by the DC city police, not 65% of all outdoor cameras in DC.

That would have been impressive, Person of Interest style.


Yes 65% is a soundbite.

Cameras are notoriously easy to break into. I would venture to say those 123 cameras has the same manufacturer and share the same reset instruction.


A false soundbite.

The first sentence of the article has more detail but is still false. Then the second sentence of the article contradicts the first sentence, adding the phrase "of the DC city police". Shall we believe that version?


That looks cool. I like th smaller form-factor and RJ45 100Mbps port.

I need one now. Thanks!


I use the Neo2 for a seedbox/VPN. $14.99 with gbe


Which of these are readily available for around the price listed?

Also, can anybody vouch for the Espressobin? 3 gigabit ports, usb3, and SATA. Nice.


The hardware is nice. The mini PCIe appears to be temperamental depending on which board you've used and there's little to no support from the vendor - they seem to have released everything, then disappeared.


All of them AFAIK. Even the Zero W can (finally) be had with relative ease, I just ordered one from SparkFun and Adafruit also has 'em in stock. Been wanting to make one into a security camera but they have been hard to get until just recently.


I think it depends on what is meant by "readily available". It's hard to do something like buy more than a couple Zero-W's at $10 apiece, unless things have changed very recently. In the past, I've seen people wanting to use a few dozen in a project having trouble finding that many for uninflated prices.


Yeah I abandoned a kickstarter roll out because I discovered I couldn't buy 1000 ... My guess is that they're losing a little on each one


I can't see why they would though. I don't think the RPF has the resources to sell so many units at a loss. I suspect it's probably just barely breaking even on both. The Wifi chipset the Zero W uses costs exactly $5 in quantity according to Digikey; the board layout is slightly different but otherwise the bill of materials is the same so that's the main cost difference. They're probably making some profits off of the accessories like the case or the camera (especially the camera, which is pretty expensive and I expect fairly popular).


Microcenter will sell you a single W for $5.

If you buy more than one, it is over $10 each and increases based on quantity.

Of course, I am lured in every time I am near and have a few Ws, and definitely spend more than $5.


Very true. It's definitely hard to get more than a couple still. But they aren't perpetually sold out anymore, at least. That is definitely an improvement in the availability that has occurred in the past couple months, so maybe their supply is finally settling down.



* SATA I or SATA II or SATA III ?


Probably "SATA 3.0"

based on this: https://www.marvell.com/docs/embedded-processors/assets/marv...

"The Marvell® ARMADA® 3700 SoC family incorporates rich high-speed I/Os including USB 3.0, SATA 3.0, Gigabit Ethernet (1 GbE) and 2.5 GbE (NBASE-T) off ering two confi gurations: 88F3720 for dual-core and 88F3710 for single-core, both confi gurations have industrial temperature grade support. In addition, these devices feature a wide set of security and data acceleration engines suitable for innovative networking, storage, and computing applications. The ARMADA 3700 supports advanced power management technologies for switching the CPU cores, as well as per-core dynamic voltage and frequency scaling. This solution off ers a signifi cant reduction in power consumption under diff erent workloads and delivers an optimal Performance-per-Watt in the embedded markets."


Rectal exams.


I am interested in the criteria you have identified.

Would you be willing to discuss this further? I have some silly ideas.


The virus kills the host?


The title had no spelling errors.


But the body text has quite a few.


Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: