> The information cost of making the RNN state way bigger is high when done naively, but maybe someone can figure out a clever way to avoid storing full hidden states in memory during training or big improvements in hardware could make memory use less of a bottleneck.
Isn't this essentially what Mamba [1] does via its 'Hardware-aware Algorithm'?
> It's astounding to me (and everyone else who's being honest) that LLMs can accomplish what they do when it's only linear "factors" (i.e. weights) that are all that's required to be adjusted during training, to achieve genuine reasoning.
When such basic perceptrons are scaled enormously, it becomes less surprising that they can achieve some level of 'genuine reasoning' (e.g., accurate next-word prediction), since the goal with such networks at the end of the day is just function approximation. What is more surprising to me is how we found ways to train such models i.e., advances in hardware accelerators, combined with massive data, which are factors just as significant in my opinion.
Yeah, no one is surprised that LLMs do what they're trained to do: predict tokens. The surprise comes from the fact that merely training to predict tokens ends up with model weights that generate emergent reasoning.
If you want to say reasoning and token prediction are just the same thing at scale you can say that, but I don't fall into that camp. I think there's MUCH more to learn, and indeed a new field of math or even physics that we haven't even discovered yet. Like a step change in mathematical understanding analogous to the invention of Calculus.
> I remember one of the initial transformer people saying in an interview that they didn't think this was the "one true architecture" but a lot of the performance came from people rallying around it and pushing in the one direction.
You may be referring to Aidan Gomez (CEO of Cohere and contributor to the transformer architecture) during his Machine Learning Street Talk podcast interview. I agree, if as much attention had been put towards the RNN during the initial transformer hype, we may have very well seen these advancements earlier.
