Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So maybe 15% isn't much when you consider how difficult it is to build your own e-store?

15% isn't much when you consider how difficult it is to acquire a customer.

Everyone I've loaded onto Amazon already has their own e-store. But here's what happens...Sales increases 10 to 20% almost instantly. But profits don't because of the 15% commission.

If you have a premium product with a large margin and no e-store, Amazon can be a great way to get orders. Otherwise, Amazon should be used to acquire customers for future direct sales. 15% is just too high for a commodity product.



Interesting. Everyone I've bought from on the Amazon Marketplace has totally failed to "recruit" me as a customer. I typically get a box with what I ordered in it, and maybe an invoice. Nothing asking me to visit their website or anything like that, ever.


This is my experience as well. the amazon site seems to make it look like I'm buying through amazon, though it's actually sold by 'some company in the small print'

I agree with the OP that 15% is pretty high for selling commodity stuff, but amazon seems, ah, sub optimal for lead generation because they make it look very similar to just buying from amazon. Like you, I've never gone from buying through amazon to buying direct from a merchant.

I think in some cases, the 15% might work out. As far as I can tell, when you buy in small lots you can often get a better deal than larger, more "reliable" lots, just 'cause someone further up the chain from you took a loss, (like someone bought a bunch, then went out of business and liquidated the lot at below-cost prices.) or because corruption is such a large problem (the larger the corporation, the more kickbacks are expected, as far as I can tell. If I own the company, kickbacks aren't going to get me to choose an overall more expensive vendor, it's my money, either way.)

either way, from what I've seen, often smaller lots from smaller resellers can be had cheaper than larger lots from more reputable resellers, even after you amortise out fraud/misrepresentation losses, so it's possible that the guy who sold me the cheap ESD wristbands on amazon really has more margin on the product than amazon direct would have.


A long time ago, Abebooks recruited me as a customer like this.. They were selling on amazon market place and with their follow up to my order convinced me to visit their website.

So, I think it can be done, I'm just surprised that not more company do it...


Ironic that Abebooks, of all sites, managed to convert you: they are an Amazon subsidiary.


They are now, but they weren't back then (I think it was around 2005)...

But I guess that if Amazon bought them, it shows they were good at what they did :-)




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: