Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It REALLY doesn't matter and it only bothers people who don't speak gendered languages.

May depend on place and culture. I recall my French teacher in 4th grade got snide about this while explaining that even a single man in a group will turn the group masculine. She was francophone.

This certainly bothers anglos much much more though.



It doesn't turn the group masculine, it turns the word used to the masculine plural, which is the generic word for a group of people.

But if you take sciences, for example, it's plural feminine in French and Italian.

If you put a masculine discipline in the group, for example "law" which is masculine in Italian (il diritto), the group of disciplines is still referred to as feminine "le scienze"

It's a matter of gender of the plural word, it has nothing to do with biological sex.


Thanks! Good points. I half wonder if my teacher’s grievance didn’t come from living in a majority anglo culture.


I remember when I realized this learning Spanish that it made me a little sad that I could only ever be part of ellos and not ellas.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: