Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Crypto is not a pyramid scheme, it is not a Ponzi scheme either. Call it a bubble, tulips, "greater fool", pump-and-dump... if you don't believe in the latest crypto-scheme, but pyramid schemes and Ponzi schemes are something different.

For pyramid schemes, the idea is that you have to pay to enter a network, and you make money by recruiting new members. The system breaks down once there a no people left to recruit, which happen quickly due to the exponential nature of the scheme. The core of a pyramid scheme is the filiation system, there is no such thing in, say, a NFT market. You can make a pyramid scheme with cryptocurrencies, but none of the popular trends are. Ponzi schemes are also not pyramid schemes.

Ponzi schemes involve a promise of unrealistic returns on investment, and they do get paid, at least in the early phase. The trick is that the returns come from new investors, and the system breaks down when people stop investing. A Ponzi scheme requires a secretive central authority that pays out the promised interests. And by nature, cryptocurrencies have no central authority and make no promise, so, not a Ponzi scheme.

Instead, crypto-schemes are simply based on speculation. And if it is a scam, it is a different kind of scam.

If we start calling anything a pyramid/Ponzi scheme, the very idea of trade and investment become a pyramid/Ponzi scheme. It will always be the case that early adopters will get more money if the (honest or not) thing takes off, this is a direct consequence of the risks involved.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: