Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Parent underappreciates that the difference between (nothing) and (anything) is infinite, and the difference between (less good) and (better) is finite.


No. I am appreciating that there are better somethings than this something, and I even explicitly recommended one.

Take the time to actually read and understand before criticizing.


In this instance (as with most of life, sometimes including time), money is the limited resource.

Suggesting OP not buy anything or spend 3.5x as much isn't helpful.


I suggested they buy a second hand kona hard tail for the same price or cheaper.


Second hand prices for Kona ebikes don't look nearly in the range of $700.

Is there a specific model you're thinking of?


They make it pretty clear that they’re sneering at the idea of the “e” part being a hard requirement.


Or maybe an emtb at that price point is simply unrealistic[1]. Which sucks because ebikes are such an accessibility boon.

[1] requiring a reputable manufacturer, even accounting for second-hand bikes. Conversion might be an option, I don't know what those run.


To me it just sounds like the PC gamers who insist that anyone who wants to 'game' needs an RTX 3070 at a minimum. They have unrealistic ideas of what the person actually wants to do. Someone who's spending a small amount on mountain bikes isn't going hard downhill.


I really don't think any analogies to PCs and games works. This is more like taking an underpowered car on the freeway. Yeah it's going to be able to get up to speed but without the acceleration that's really needed. And I don't know that I would have known better when I'd first gotten my license without being told. We don't know that someone wouldn't take this bike on well-maintained trails a few times and then decide to "graduate" to jumping over roots and rocks or w/e.

Not to mention not knowing how well the electric part is done, especially the battery. I'd be ok taking my $200 commuter on some light trail because I'm mechanically inclined and I've got the measure of it. I have no idea about how to assess the electricals but given the cost-cutting, bad workmanship, and bad design I can see in the rest of the bike's build, I'd be really concerned about that.

"Whether you are a professional athlete" lmao




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: