Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I just don't understand how many people prefer these keyboards.

Key travel is only important to assist in your typing + provide feedback, but unless you type like a brute (I've a friend whom I would NEVER lend my laptop too, as I would be worried for my keyboard) or have sensory nerve issues like from diabetes, you don't need much travel.

I was dubious of the newest Lenovo keyboards, but after using my X1 Nano for a few hours, I was convinced: while the keys themselves have less travel, it has a strong opposing force that gives a lot of feedback.

It's still a bit too stiff for my taste (it seems to have been made for big burly guys) and I'd prefer something more like the current Macbook keyboards, a self-avowed heresy for any Thinkpad fan :)



It's funny to think about Lenovo making the X1 Nano for big burly guys.

It's too bad that laptop switches will likely never see the huge and varied aftermarket that we have with mechanical keyboards. There's a switch for everyone, and it'll work in almost any keyboard if you're handy with a soldering iron or have one with hotswappable switch sockets.


> It's too bad that laptop switches will likely never see the huge and varied aftermarket that we have with mechanical keyboards. There's a switch for everyone

Is there one for me, who likes little key travel, softness, and silence?

So far the best solution I've found : thinkpad USB keyboards everywhere :)


Possibly a lightweight Kailh Choc linear switch? They’re very soft and quiet, but they have no tactility. The tactile ones leave a bit to be desired. It’s hard to match rubber domes there.

https://mkultra.click/choc-switches


> It’s hard to match rubber domes there.

Indeed. Even if it's antithetical to the mechanical keyboard idea, I wish MX style keycaps (wide availability, for ex this is how I could get a Cyrillic keyboard) could be made compatible with rubber domes (with no mechanical switch)


This was somewhat common with Alps, actually. They made a rubber dome slider that was compatible with their mechanical mount.

https://deskthority.net/wiki/Alps_dome_with_slider




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: