Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Imho all robo advisers are a waste of money.

Robo and human financial advisors provide emotional hand-holding and comfort.

Same reason why you trust a doctor, despite doctors underperforming (intelligent) self-directed health and nutrition research.



> Same reason why you trust a doctor, despite doctors underperforming (intelligent) self-directed health and nutrition research.

I’m skeptical of this claim. What’s “intelligent” research mean?

Index funds are literally sit it and forget it. Even easier than robo advisers. With year retirement funds you even get auto balancing with the same ease.


Self-directed surgery? Joking aside, providing structure to investments and investment decisions is probably helpful for some.


> self-directed health and nutrition research

That's a bold statement considering the anti-vaccine climate today. The value in doctors isn't necessarily what they've learned but instead what trends they've seen personally and local to your area.

I do agree human financial advisors are mainly a tool for comfort. I've got one and most of our conversations instigated by him are relationship-building and not necessarily aggessive-fund-strategy type talk.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: