Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It really blows my mind that the US makes it so hard to get in legally and stay.

Huh, why it blows your mind? Is it some kind of human right that anyone can come to US at any point in time and just start living there. Besides if they are so talented why they can't stay in home country and apply the talent.



I would think that a significant proportion of native born American households (including most politicians) have at least one immigrant grandparent, and the conditions that led to them leaving their native home. You would think that a people who are well acquainted with their own relatively recent roots in the country would be more open to the idea in general.


Noone's not open to it. Everyone is open to legal immigration.

We'd have more resources available if there was less illegal immigration.

Everyone wants reform. More border security, less visa lotteries. Visas on merit.


>We'd have more resources available if there was less illegal immigration.

Wrong. The resources are under the control of the capital elite. They can decide at any time to allocate them to suit socially useful purposes, horde them or gamble them on the latest NFT fad.

Immigrants have no control over resource allocation.


Well, the response to your comment was right there in the second sentence you, for some reason, failed to quote: "The US is turning away so many talented individuals that could vastly add to the nation in many different ways."


No, but if I'm running a country and talented people want to move to my country and bring their skills, then I would want to open my borders to them. That way my country will theoretically be better off than other countries.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: