Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>In fact, I recently paid for my parent's hospital bills and did it happily.

Yes and I recently paid thousands of dollars for my wife's hospital bill, would you like a cookie? That's how it's supposed to work: you voluntarily decide to help your loved ones and the payment is made.

How it isn't supposed to work is that the elderly make a moral judgement that the youth are less deserving of investment than themselves, and involuntarily they extract that money from the youth without their consent. I have no problem with a society where you voluntarily pay your parent's hospital bill, in fact you can do that in most any country already. Congratulations, your goal is already achieved.

>we end up paying for things we don't like regardless of our opinions

In this case you seem to mean we are made to pay for others without our consent.

>I think healthcare should be a priority..

Maybe I think hookers should be a priority; sex is correlated with good health. You wouldn't mind if I took a couple hundred from you for my health would you?



> Maybe I think hookers should be a priority; sex is correlated with good health. You wouldn't mind if I took a couple hundred from you for my health would you?

Well, different priorities, and that’s fine.

But, let’s assume in a democracy, the majority of people decide to vote for free hookers and blow for everyone, why not :)


>But, let’s assume in a democracy, the majority of people decide to vote for free hookers and blow for everyone, why not :)

Majority of _what_ people. The majority of people within my square mile? This continent? The majority of people in my house? I merely reduce down 'democracy' to its logical smallest element, the individual. I vote what I will spend my earnings on, and as the only voter my vote wins. Of course, my vote has no effect on obligation of others, as they are not part of my own 'democracy.'

Very few people want a pure democracy. Pure democracy is 5 people in a house, and 4 vote to beat the shit out of the fifth. Pure democracy is when 60% whites vote to make blacks their slaves. Pure democracy is voting to intern the Japanese in camps.

Voting is fine, involuntary extraction of resources from others is not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: