Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yeah there is. I surf with JS off because of people like you.


Most of the data you can collect with Plausible could just be collected server side instead, it's nothing like Google Analytics.


> Most of the data you can collect with Plausible could just be collected server side instead

Then why not just use that instead?


SPAs & marketing teams are used to snippets


https://plausible.io/privacy-focused-web-analytics

You surf with JS off because of sites abusing their users' data. This is not it.


Collecting data that a user doesn't want collected is abuse. It doesn't matter what you do with it.


Oof. Hard disagree on that one, way too black & white of a position for me in the face of such a broad concept as "data".


> You surf with JS off because of sites abusing their users' data. This is not it.

Wrong. I surf with JS off because of sites that use JS to collect information about me.

If it's available on the server, then sure that might be considered fair game. But using javascript (or any other client-side tool) to do what you should instead do server-side is abusing users (or their data).

Putting analytics inline so it's "not ad-blocked by a url request" is absolutely disrespecting users and a perfect reason to turn off javascript.


> Wrong. I surf with JS off because of sites that use JS to collect information about me.

Plausible doesn't collect information about you, but the site's usage. Do you also object to physical stores putting up cameras?

Here's their own instance, open to public.

https://plausible.io/plausible.io

> If it's available on the server, then sure that might be considered fair game. But using javascript (or any other client-side tool) to do what you should instead do server-side is abusing users (or their data).

That's quite the affirmation. Is this fact or opinion?


> Plausible doesn't collect information about you, but the site's usage. Do you also object to physical stores putting up cameras?

The difference is that the cameras don't get attached to my physical body, doesn't have any ability to monitor my actions after I have left the presence of the physical store, and can't force me to take any physical item or action.

Javascript, on the other hand, has the capability to become persistent, can monitor my computer's activity outside of your website, and can leave a lot (!) of additional data on my computer without my permission.


> doesn't have any ability to monitor my actions after I have left the presence of the physical store

What a coincidence, Plausible doesn't either.


Also notice how I said "analytics package" and not "tracking" in my comment, because there is no tracking. I mean, unless you're the only visitor from a specific country, there is literally 0 identifying data in Plausible.


Analytics is still unnecessary JS and a bandwidth hog, so it has to go.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: