Holy crap, this 100%. I am absolutely distraught. I give monthly donations, have moved mountains to get family and friends over to Signal, and viewed it as a last bastion for security and interoperability between iOS and Android. Now we will get neither.
Gutted. I will end up switching to a different provider. Absolutely don't know if I'll be able to convince family and friends to switch again.
I don't really see Signal as a useful tool for my uses after this change. I liked the SMS and encrypted messages in one place thing even though some friends rarely check it. For those friends I send SMS through Signal. There are certainly issues with group chats and media but nothing bad enough to consider using two apps. Now I have to look for a new tool, and figure out what to do with certain archive conversations I'd like to retain.
>viewed it as a last bastion for security and interoperability between iOS and Android
>Now we will get neither
Correct me if I'm wrong, but:
- If you and your counterparty are both using Signal, nothing about the security of your communication changes.
- If your counterparty was not using Signal, your messages were over SMS/MMS and therefore not encrypted in the first place, and so once again, nothing about the security of your communication changes.
That's definitely true! But if both are in one app you don't need to remember who uses Signal and who doesn't; it just works. Now with two apps, you have to run that mental check before sending a message and choose the right app.
Gutted. I will end up switching to a different provider. Absolutely don't know if I'll be able to convince family and friends to switch again.