See, this is exactly why I didn't want to cite any particular study or analysis.
I knew this was going to turn into this pointless debate.
I even mentioned it in my parent comment that you can always find some study which says the opposite of what I'm saying. That does not refute what I said and it is not how science works.
You have to analyze a bunch of evidence, from many studies and meta-studies together as a whole, you can't just pick and choose the studies that are more convenient to you.
Not to mention that you asked me to cite a meta-analysis (which I did) and then you counter-act with a single study about a single trial.
So here's the thing: I am not interested in you citing me any study or meta-analysis. As I said before, I'm not interested in continuing this discussion.
I was just arguing what I know about this topic and what I've learned from experts (in psychology and methodology, mostly) and my own research.
You can feel free to ignore me or to continue arguing, but I'm not going to answer anymore.
I don't have a horse in this race and I don't want to waste any more of my time.
You claimed psychoanalysis is discredited. You are wrong, and I proved you wrong. Is the debate about its scientific status ongoing? Yes. But you were foolish with your words, and should retract them.
I knew this was going to turn into this pointless debate.
I even mentioned it in my parent comment that you can always find some study which says the opposite of what I'm saying. That does not refute what I said and it is not how science works.
You have to analyze a bunch of evidence, from many studies and meta-studies together as a whole, you can't just pick and choose the studies that are more convenient to you.
Not to mention that you asked me to cite a meta-analysis (which I did) and then you counter-act with a single study about a single trial.
So here's the thing: I am not interested in you citing me any study or meta-analysis. As I said before, I'm not interested in continuing this discussion.
I was just arguing what I know about this topic and what I've learned from experts (in psychology and methodology, mostly) and my own research.
You can feel free to ignore me or to continue arguing, but I'm not going to answer anymore.
I don't have a horse in this race and I don't want to waste any more of my time.