Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Didn't this sentiment come with hypertext? If books had clickable links we'd have a difficult time finishing them.

It's just a different way to read. Both have very obvious, very ancient, strengths and weaknesses.

When you get sick of take out, you can go garden. When you get sick of gardening, get take out.




Academic and some nonacademic books have citations and/or footnotes. Those can be followed, though with somewhat more effort than simply clicking a link. As a positive, however, proper citations rarely suffer linkrot, though some references are obscure, and if you're looking at ancient works, there may well be entirely lost works.

What I've found over the past decade or so as more books are available online (with varying levels of copyright compliance), it's possible to hit a reference and trace it often within a minute or so of searching. That's both delightful and something of a tarpit, reading lists can grow with amazing rapidity.

One of the first times I realised this was when reading through James Burke's Connections (companion book to the 1970s television series), and seeing a reference to Agricola's De re Metallica, a Renaissance-era text on mining and metallurgy still used as a reference through the 19th century.

Within a few minutes I located it (English translation, by an American couple, Lou Henry and Herbert Hoover) on the Internet Archive:

<https://archive.org/details/georgiusagricola00agri/page/n3/m...>

There's also a Project Gutenberg version: <https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/38015>


> Didn't this sentiment come with hypertext? If books had clickable links we'd have a difficult time finishing them.

Absolutely!

I think that the hyper-twitch consumption model has become so ubiquitous that some people have forgotten how to slow down, though.

I prefer the slow model, personally, but I was born before the internet went big.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: