Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Imagine you live in a world where no part of the build has to repeat unless the changes actually impacted it. A world in which all builds happened with automatic parallelism. A world in which you could reproduce very reliably any part of the build on your laptop.

That sounds similar to https://concourse-ci.org/

I quite like it, but it never seemed to gain traction outside of Cloud Foundry.



We spent some time evaluating this on my team, and we're still experimenting with it.

I like it a lot, but the project appears to be mostly unmaintained since mid-2021, when the creator left it to work on a lispy CI/CD tool [0] that feels very complicated... not sure what's going on there.

[0]: https://github.com/vito/bass


There are folks still working on it but at this point it pretty much only gets updates that VMware needs to continue delivering Cloud Foundry. It looks dead-er than it is because the team hasn't explained this, so there's a giant list of work that won't ever get done just kinda... hanging out... on the README and in the issues list.

I use it at work but it was already running when I got there. I also really like it but I'd be reluctant to stand it up somewhere new unless I was using it to run a Cloud Foundry. It has some operational issues and it is actually impossible to get an SLA if you're not also a VMware Cloud Foundry customer, and that costs a minimum of $50k per year.


I enjoyed working with concourse as the foundations of Pivotal's release engineering systems. We tried several other platforms, but ultimately concourse was tailor-made for Pivotal-style dev/ops ie highly technical, prioritizing version-control and CLIs over GUIs, with the wall-mounted "build monitor" as a first-class user. While Concourse wasn't explicitly a Pivotal product, shouldn't Conway's Law encourage us not to understate the influences of the Pivotal milieu?

I don't doubt that VMware failed to nurture Concourse's maintenance post-acquisition. I hesitate to make sweeping statements about the legendary virtualization behemoth, but I personally doubt their commitment XP dev/ops culture.

Edit: don't take my word for it, read someone more closely involved to this day, Nat Bennett https://www.simplermachines.com/some-facts-about-concourse/




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: