Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

1. Suppose the OP did not take the source code files, but memorized the source code and later recalled it from memory. Would that be theft?

2. Suppose the OP neither took the file nor memorized the code, but had photographic memory and replayed the exact visual scenes during their creation of the utility functions and copied down the code from what they saw in their mind's eye. Would that be theft?

3. Suppose the OP was solving a seemingly novel problem and suddenly remembered how they solved the exact same problem when they were employed by company X. Are they obligated to banish this solution from their mind?



> 1. Suppose the OP did not take the source code files, but memorized the source code and later recalled it from memory. Would that be theft?

It is copyright infringement, yes. That's why clean room implementations are done by someone who hasn't seen the original source code,

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design

For the other examples, it depends but I'm pretty sure a copyright infringement case for either of them wouldn't be immediately thrown out. IANAL but I do know that law is quite fuzzy.


Suppose the OP wrote the original source code files and recreated them from their own intuition of the problem. Would that be theft?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: