Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can someone eli5 how this works. Wouldn’t the phone expend a lot of power to transmit?



transmitter doesn't need to be super powerful if the receiver is super sensitive


If commercial satellites can pick up individual cellphone signals and receive them with no modifications, the military would have this tech for years?

Just listening on where devices are currently and the signal power strength (must be higher while calling/transmitting data) could be a major source of signal intelligence.


Not necessarily, starlink satellite and receiver are the cutting edge technology. Raytheon may have this technology years ago in their skunkwork equivalent but the military never formally bought anything like that.


Military doesn't need same quality to monitor, Starlink needs to also transmit and receive data(albeit slow speed), a military sat would just need to listen for a signal and know active and possibly identify some characteristics which combined other data sources Signal Int will have access to could be used to uniquely identify.

Starlink satellites are designed to be cheap(<$1M) and small in weight (~1,000Kg) and size(fit 20-60 in Falcon 9), and lot of the innovation is manufacturing at scale.

I am skeptical they come anywhere close to purpose built military satellites which costs upwards of $300-$400M[1] and are much larger in weight (5,000Kg-10,000+) and size (use full fairing ) and fly DH, Atlas as well and lever vertical integration. Given what we know about KH-11s, Trump photo tweet, the tech in the donated mirrors etc Military seem generation ahead in production tech not just experimental ones.

[1] There is some pork for sure in all government contracts, but not $299M worth.


And/or if you can take a really long time to send your message. It’s ultimately a question of energy per bit.


I suppose the fact that it's LOS reduces the power requirements. There's really no way around it: they specifically stress that the UE is unmodified.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: