Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Been doing this software thing for a bit now… while what you say is true in that it is possible in some rare cases, I think it’s a bit of a straw man exception. Code is, in the general sense, unfortunately never complete, regardless of how complete it seems in its context.

The issue is that the context is always changing. It is almost like suggesting there is an evolutionarily perfect organism. At best, one suited perfectly well to the current context can exist, but that perfect suitability falls off the second the environment changes. And the environment always changes.

I totally get the sentiment, but I think the idea that any code is ever complete is unfortunately just not a realistic one to apply outside of select and narrow contexts.



If I wrote a library to open jpegs, it correctly loads all standard jpegs, and it's free of security issues - is that not complete?

It's not like it's desirable for standard formats to one day start getting interpreted in a different way.


It's free of security issues in the current context, that's the point.

You depend on calling a standard library function that was found deficient (maybe it's impossible to make it secure) and deprecated. Now there is a new function you should call. Your software doesn't work anymore when the deprecated function is removed.

Sure, you can say your software is feature complete but you have to specify the external environment it's supposed to run on. And THAT is always changing.

You're both right but looking at different timelines.

Relevant: https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/software-engineering-at...


> and it's free of security issues

That's a biiiiig if


Just to add another thing that changes to the other ones which were already mentioned by sibling comments: “standard jpegs” are not necessarily set in stone.


Another Clojure programmer just got her parentheses-encrusted wings.

There are Clojure packages that go untouched for years... not because they're abandoned, but because they are stable and good enough.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: