> I think it's pretty silly to say that Tao is the best living mathematician
I agree. I was going to write "one of the best" or "probably the best" or something like that. It's like discussing if Messi or Maradona were the best football players. [1]. Anyway, all three of them are quite good.
> but even if he were I don't think that this would be a useful way to think about things.
I also agree. It's just and argument by authority. For a decition that would change the lives of millons of persons and has a lot of subtle tradeoff and unknown unknowns, I'd ask for a better justification and evidence. But deciding if this is a breakthrough or not, may only change the lives of a few graduate students and a few grown up mathematicians, so I'm happy to take the word of Tao.
I agree. I was going to write "one of the best" or "probably the best" or something like that. It's like discussing if Messi or Maradona were the best football players. [1]. Anyway, all three of them are quite good.
> but even if he were I don't think that this would be a useful way to think about things.
I also agree. It's just and argument by authority. For a decition that would change the lives of millons of persons and has a lot of subtle tradeoff and unknown unknowns, I'd ask for a better justification and evidence. But deciding if this is a breakthrough or not, may only change the lives of a few graduate students and a few grown up mathematicians, so I'm happy to take the word of Tao.
[1] Hi from Argentina!