Out of all of these, I've only tried Yabai. It's fine. Things mostly work like I expect them to and I rarely encounter a situation that isn't fixed by restarting Yabai. That said, I'm hardly a power user. I have not disabled SIP and instead simulate features that would require it as best as possible through other means. E.g. workspaces can be switched by dispatching a key combination that is handled by macOS natively.

You can check out my configs here [0] if you are so inclined, but it's not super polished.

[0] https://github.com/Cu3PO42/gleaming-glacier/tree/next