Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What's the issue with having a span represent "one year and two months"? Both involve a variable number of days (365-366 and 28-31), but I would hope you could store the components separately so it can be unambiguously applied once given a specific moment in time.

I'm thinking something along the lines of how ActiveSupport::Duration works:

    >> 4.years + 5.months + 3.weeks + 2.days + 1.hour + 4.minutes + 10.seconds
    => 4 years, 5 months, 3 weeks, 2 days, 1 hour, 4 minutes, and 10 seconds
Of course the downside being that it would need to be sized large enough to contain each component, even though they may be rarely used.


The components are stored separately. I think what you are advocating for is component wise addition, which I mentioned in my previous comment. It can totally "work," but as I said, it will produce different results than `span1.checked_add(span2)`. For example:

    use jiff::{ToSpan, Unit, Zoned};

    fn main() -> anyhow::Result<()> {
        let span1 = 1.year().months(3);
        let span2 = 11.months();
        let now = Zoned::now().round(Unit::Minute)?;
        let added = span1.checked_add((span2, &now))?;
        println!("{added}");

        Ok(())
    }
Has this output:

    $ cargo -q r
    P2y2m
Notice how the months overflow automatically into years. Days will do the same into months. You need a reference point to do this correctly. For example, just `span1.checked_add(span2)?` would produce an error.

In contrast, component wise addition would lead to a span of `1 year 14 months`. Which is a valid `Span`. Jiff is fine with it. But it's different than what `checked_add` does. Having both operations seems too subtle.

Also, I don't really think using the `+` operator just to construct spans is that much of a win over what Jiff already has. So that needs to be taken into account as well.


The Into<SpanArithmetic> argument feels a little too magical. Since you are not constrained by a trait, I would prefer something like

    Span::add_with_reference(&self, other: &Span, reference: impl Into<SpanRelativeTo>)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: