Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is making that company not look very good, is it?!


Awful company. They could post “here are our standard job roles, we aren’t actively hiring but if you’re the perfect match please tell us why”, which warns the prospective applicant.


Doesn't hurt them either I don't think. Nobody knows. It sucks because the whole job hunting system is borked.


> Doesn't hurt them either I don't think.

Well those are 3000 resumes that won't be resubmitted when you actually want to hire. Many of those resumes will belong to people who since found work. Weeding through that would be a nightmare, so you'd have to toss it and write it off as a loss.

Or you could just post jobs when you're actually interested in hiring and turn it off when you have enough applications to process. Super interested candidates can always cold email.


They don't care about those 3k and they could reach out.

And maybe next round they do apply again. I sure don't remember when I last was applying who I applied for except some big names that ... yeah I'd submit it again if I was looking.

I don't like the system, but I don't think they're hurt by it.


If 500 people apply for a fake job and don’t get to an interview or personal response stage, then when they need a real job filling they’ve already wiped out a lot of applicants who won’t bother applying next time.


I doubt that's how it works out. Last time I was looking I applied so many places I can't remember most of them.


Presumably you’re not putting much effort then?


It is not making that company look very good.

Enticing job seekers to waste their very precious time is not ethical.

Edit: fix double negative.


Just an FYI.. the double negative means you said it makes the company look good.

(I don't think you intended that)


Thank you - fixed it.


What do you mean? They have open roles so they must be growing? Seems like a good investment.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: