After getting frustrated by the game not accepting my responses to the obvious clues repeatedly I resorted to clicking on each person and selecting both Innocent and Criminal.
- "My only innocent neighbor is to the left of Harold"
- "Barb and I have one innocent neighbor in common"
Thank you for taking the time to go through this. The hint should be clarified. It means "somewhere to the left", so on the same row to the left. It is either Freya or Gary since they are both to the left og Harold, and common neighbors of Barb and Cheryl. You have no way of knowing which one yet. This will be clarified in future puzzles.
- "My only innocent neighbor is to the left of Harold"
- "Barb and I have one innocent neighbor in common"
- Implies Gary is a criminal
But the game won't let me.