Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Either racism is bad or it’s not. Whether the consequence of it is better or worse for one group or another is irrelevant if the principle that racism is bad is adhered to.

And I’d argue the consequences aren’t that different. If someone is passed over for a job, pulled over by cops, denied the ability to purchase a house, those all have equal levels of consequence for the person on the receiving end.

I think the statement as art was brilliant. It forced those who play lip service to “all men are created equal” to put themselves and try to explain why a rather uncontroversial statement was so controversial. It was wild seeing them twist themselves into a knot trying to explain why it was so bad.



> And I’d argue the consequences aren’t that different.

This is wrong. (Systemic) racism (still) exists. Someone who has natural advantages in society (white men) does not suffer the same consequences of the events you listed:

- "passed over for a job" Jobs are easier to get for white people in the US, no? - "pulled over by cops" really? - "denied the ability to purchase a house" redlining has denied a lot of wealth to black families in the US

> those all have equal levels of consequence for the person on the receiving end.

So, this is not true.


Whether something is “more bad” is irrelevant to whether or not it “is bad”.

Whether I punch you once or twice in the face, it’s still bad, so both are against the law.

What you’re saying is “its ok to punch someone in the face once because it’s not as bad as punching them in the face twice”

Clearly an absurd position.


>Someone who has natural advantages in society (white men)

White men no longer have natural advantages. As a matter of fact the Supreme Court agreed that White and Asian males are now at a natural disadvantage.


Yup. It sad to see leftists contort themselves into loving racism as long as the target is approved by the Party, academia, the previous administration, etc. Since the clergy has approved the target, it is therefore just and moral.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: