Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Keep in mind that when writing your own "engine," you don't need it to be as general as possible to handle every possible kind of game. You just need it to handle your game.

And there are plenty of libraries and frameworks that can be pulled in to handle things like UI, compression, etc. The OP uses imGUI which is an excellent, small UI library for making in-game editors.

When choosing to go down that path you're not making, "an engine for all games." So there is a ton of work you're not doing.



It is still a lot of work.

And every external libary you do pull in, to ease some of the workload, is just waiting to go abandonend next year. So instead of focusing on release by that time, you will now focus on reinplementing that needed functionality that just stopped working.


> So instead of focusing on release by that time, you will now focus on reinplementing that needed functionality that just stopped working.

That makes no sense. A library being abandoned doesn't mean it suddenly stops working.


I wish that would be the case, but on the web stack, it happened more than once to me.

The web evolves. Lots of features get deprecated all the time and sometimes removed or change behavior in a significant way.


The library would continue to work but may no longer be usable if other dependencies require a later version of "n" that the abandoned library is incompatible with. Ruby or Python runtimes are the classic example.


Support for any studio larger than a few people is the most important part of 3rd party tools. If (and inevitably, when) a tool has a bug or can't do something you need, there's reassurance being able to tell someone else to fix the problem.

Using abandoned tools either means you're very sure all use cases are covered, or that your own engineers are willing to hack around should it not be sufficient. And I think anyone who works with legacy code knows that navigating already written codebases without guidance can take just as long as whipping up a custom implementation.


Definitely, it’s a trade off. Pulling in dubious dependencies can be a risk. Might be worth writing your own library or forking the dependency and vendoring it in your source.

There’s a spectrum of options here.


This is really the case for all engines. Unity is a bit of of an outlier, though took a long time to get where it is.

Unreal Engine is really the Unreal Tournament/Gears of War engine at its core.

Good engines are those that are focused on what the game needs. YAGNI/KISS apply here too




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: