Ah yes, automated lawsuit initiation, that's what we need! Ooh, we could run every breach announcement through Deep Research and let the AI make a determination on which one is negligence! That would definitely incentivize more transparency and accountability on behalf of companies!
Actually no, the end result of this will be a return to deny, deny, deny, because the worst case scenario then becomes the truth getting out.
IMHO we should be crucifying the liars and the truly negligent, but forgiving the honest and good faith efforts. At least for now, automating that judgment is pretty difficult and will result in more of the "customer service" like experiences that we already get from most big tech, except now it has the power to make or break companies.
Man we have sure moved on from the era of Blackstone's Ratio being a thing people united around. I'm not saying it should be applied literally, but punishing an innocent person should be considered a lot more wrong than not punishing a guilty person IMHO.
“Based on the investigation into this incident, it was determined that the
information involved may include your name, Social Security number, date of
birth, Driver’s License number (if provided), Tribal ID number (if provided),
medical record number, treatment, diagnosis, prescription and other medical
information, health insurance information, member portal username and
password, email address, and address.”
It’s not about innocence or guilt. If you leak so much information these people will have to monitor every single account, credit card, etc for life, on top of all their personal sensitive info being leaked and possibly accessed by unscrupulous employers. The damage is incredible. It’s not about innocence. It’s about responsibility.
I guess I should clarify: for incidents like that, I agree there should be severe consequences and blowback, including class action lawsuits and the like. If you are collecting stuff like SSN, DoB, DL number, etc then you definitely have a huge responsibility to protect that. I want to make data like that radioactive to collect so people think very carefully about whether they want to take on the liability.
What I don't think should happen is some automated lawyer combing the internet looking for any disclosures and then automatically filing lawsuits based on it.
Actually no, the end result of this will be a return to deny, deny, deny, because the worst case scenario then becomes the truth getting out.
IMHO we should be crucifying the liars and the truly negligent, but forgiving the honest and good faith efforts. At least for now, automating that judgment is pretty difficult and will result in more of the "customer service" like experiences that we already get from most big tech, except now it has the power to make or break companies.
Man we have sure moved on from the era of Blackstone's Ratio being a thing people united around. I'm not saying it should be applied literally, but punishing an innocent person should be considered a lot more wrong than not punishing a guilty person IMHO.