As I’ve mentioned here before, sideloading is a genuine security concern, not merely an excuse for Apple to exert control. There is a never-ending stream of people losing their life savings. It happens on Android and not iOS because Android allows sideloading and iOS doesn’t. There is a very real human cost to this.
> Police warn new Android malware scam can factory reset phones; over S$10 million lost in first half of 2023
> There have been more than 750 cases of victims downloading the malware into their phones in the first half of 2023, with losses of at least S$10 million (US$7.3 million).
> 74-year-old man loses $70k after downloading third-party app to buy Peking duck
> “I couldn’t believe the news. I thought: Why am I so stupid? I was so angry at myself for being cheated of my life savings. My family is frustrated and I ended up quarrelling with my wife,” said Mr Loh, who has three children.
> Singapore Android users to be blocked from installing certain unverified apps as part of anti-scam trial
> "Based on our analysis of major fraud malware families that exploit these sensitive runtime permissions, we found that over 95 per cent of installations came from internet-sideloading sources," it added.
> Android users in Singapore tried to install unverified apps nearly 900,000 times in past 6 months
> These attempts were blocked by a security feature rolled out by Google six months ago as part of a trial to better protect users against malware scams, which led to at least S$34.1 million (US$25.8 million) in losses last year with about 1,900 cases reported.
Maybe just the ones that could be used to send all your money to scammers from your bank account or crypto wallet?
Computers are cheap these days. You can buy a Raspberry Pi to hack on and use something else for your money. If you like hacking on smart phones, carrying more than one phone is an option. You don’t need root access on every device you own.
I'd want a separate, secure smartphone only for auth/banking... but Google makes this impossible by preinstalling their unremovable spyware. And if you dare to remove it, then poof - your device is no longer considered secure. Google knows what they're doing.
We should implement mechanisms that make it hard and obvious to do unsafe things and easy to do safe things, in all kinds of computers; even as an expert user, I don’t want to have to think about my text editor’s color scheme being able to access my bank. Yes, this necessarily involves a barrier to installing apps with certain privileges, and it should be high enough in software targeted at non-expert users to provide them with protection against scams. No, we obviously shouldn’t make it illegal for a user to do what they want, and nobody has even come close to proposing that here. That’s a straw man.
I'm tired of this crap where companies constantly restrict my freedom in the name of security.. the same thing happened to Chromium, where Google decided that MV2 was "insecure" so with MV3 we alsi lost the webRequestBlocking api which had nothing to do with that..
Hey, listen, I don't fall for these obvious scams and I even rarely install apps/extensions, but when I do, I know what I'm doing.
There should be a giant "OPT OUT" button (you press it, you're responsible for it) so I'd not be bothered ever again.
> Police warn new Android malware scam can factory reset phones; over S$10 million lost in first half of 2023
> There have been more than 750 cases of victims downloading the malware into their phones in the first half of 2023, with losses of at least S$10 million (US$7.3 million).
— https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/android-malware-sc...
> DBS, UOB become latest banks to restrict access if unverified apps are found on customers' phones
> They are the latest banks in Singapore to do so – after OCBC and Citibank – amid a spate of malware scams targeting users of Android devices.
— https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/dbs-uob-anti-scam-...
> 74-year-old man loses $70k after downloading third-party app to buy Peking duck
> “I couldn’t believe the news. I thought: Why am I so stupid? I was so angry at myself for being cheated of my life savings. My family is frustrated and I ended up quarrelling with my wife,” said Mr Loh, who has three children.
— https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/74-year-old-man-loses...
> Singapore Android users to be blocked from installing certain unverified apps as part of anti-scam trial
> "Based on our analysis of major fraud malware families that exploit these sensitive runtime permissions, we found that over 95 per cent of installations came from internet-sideloading sources," it added.
— https://www.channelnewsasia.com/business/anduril-secures-305...
> CNA Explains: Are Android devices more prone to malware and how do you protect yourself from scams?
> Why are scammers more likely to target Android users? How do you spot a fake app and what should you do if your device is infected by malware?
— https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/android-malware-sc...
> Nearly 2,000 victims fell for Android malware scams, at least S$34.1 million lost in 2023
> In 2023, about 1,899 cases of Android malware scams were reported in Singapore. The average amount lost was about S$17,960.
— https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/android-malware-sc...
> Android users in Singapore tried to install unverified apps nearly 900,000 times in past 6 months
> These attempts were blocked by a security feature rolled out by Google six months ago as part of a trial to better protect users against malware scams, which led to at least S$34.1 million (US$25.8 million) in losses last year with about 1,900 cases reported.
— https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/android-users-inst...