Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If it’s not an insurrection what it is? What is the organization of thousands of individuals to invade the capital building in protest of election results?

Just because it failed, doesn’t mean it wasn’t an insurrection.






Words like "protest" or "riot" leap to mind. It is more comparable to something like CHAZ in 2020 which could technically be called an insurrection or rebellion, but realistically was more of an unruly protest.

An insurrection would traditionally involve a little planning and a little more seriousness in the attempt. Maybe a plan that could conceivably lead to a change in government.


It was also a protest and a riot. These things are not mutually exclusive.

Obviously. All riots are technically insurrections. They're synonyms. And they are usually protests too; it'd be unusual to have a riot while agreeing with the current direction of the government.

roenxi 1 day ago [flagged] | | [–]

> A riot or mob violence is a form of civil disorder commonly characterized by a group lashing out in a violent public disturbance against authority, property, or people.

> Uprisings which revolt, resisting and taking direct action against an authority, law or policy

See? Riots are by definition rebellions. They're both words for resisting legitimate authority. How do you expect there to be a riot that isn't an insurrection? That's why the lefties aren't getting much pushback on calling it an insurrection. Its a riot. Everyone agrees. Insisting that it use a specific word instead of the usual one is playing a bit of a game to pretend that it is some sort of special riot which is where the pushback starts; but there isn't any question that it is technically an insurrection - all riots are small insurrections.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: