Yes, I feel like it's some new kind of uncanny valley. It's weird because in 2D it's not so bad and in Claymation it works well (Wallace and Gromit) but there's something about the hyperreal Calarts style that just is not pleasant to look at.

The Incredibles was peak Pixar character art style.

Not sure about Turning Red, but it was a common criticism of Win or Lose, their Disney+ series from a few months ago.