Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From slavery to the Chinese exclusion act to Jim Crow to the Japanese internment camps to the patriot act. It's hard to make the case we were anything but.

What has changed recently is technology collapsing the world into a single blob of information, and that aspect gets worse every year.



Despite the headline on this article you still have way more freedom and specifically freedom of speech in the US than the rest of us.

The law works differently at the border, especially for non-citizens. Tourists don't have any legal right to get in. You may argue that the guards should be kinder and I would agree.

The historical examples you mention involve racism and slavery that were terrible but also the global standard at the time.

The Patriot Act is scary, but it doesn't seem much better elsewhere in the Anglosphere or in Europe. Say something impolitic loud enough and you'll get in trouble anywhere.

Here's hoping individual freedoms win in the end.


> you still have way more freedom and specifically freedom of speech in the US than the rest of us

Depends on who "you" are.

There some some who are allowed to openly make tangible, if thinly veiled death threats to others without repercussions. Others can have their lives ruined over trivial things.

The "you"s who are not granted as much freedom of speech are aware of it and only express themselves among trusted people.


There is now an absolute fountain of criticism of the current administration, the USA itself, and the entire West coming from every demographic in the USA. This isn't a new thing or restricted to Trump. I don't see any mass arrests, chilling of media, or official propaganda making the rounds.


You are not looking. Law firms are targeted and silenced. Media is subservient. People absolutely do watch what they say for a large number of reasons.

The type of speech being policed is different, but it's absolutely happening.


You're right and I don't like it one bit, but there was also a long list of true things that we weren't allowed to say aloud under the previous lot.


Great, glad we agree. I didn't like the precious lot one bit either. Glad they're gone.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: