Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Brazil is a big place, and growing sugarcane properly actually regenerates the soil, such as if no or low till techniques are used (which are popular in Brazil).


I don’t believe there’s any evidence to suggest sugarcane regenerates soil. In fact I can only find evidence to the contrary.


even a simple rotation like corn -> soybeans can aid some bacteria recover, thus a better soil lifespan (high productive areas with proper management (beyond rotation, like some rest and proper fertilization can last ~ 120 years being abused all the year long)

probably hundreds of years if erosion wasn't a thing [0]

but "regenerating" as the OP types is probably about actively managing land recover while planting some sugarcane in between the process. now. if the harvest will be profitable for making biofuel is probably another talk

[0] just a guess


the crux of ag soil "energy" is just nitrates and stuff. some plants like beans and lentils recharge nitrogen in the soil (hence the old native american trinity or whatever, corn, beans, and some other plant). fertilizer, that's just nitrates. poop and pee (natural fertilizer).. yup, nitrates.

Basic reason would tell us, unless we're using a nitrogen-fixing plant like beans, unless we're using fertilizer, the plant's gonna suck up nitrates from the soil, get harvested, and now there's less nitrates in the soil. Weakening the soil quality thusly. Pretty straightforward.

Biologically you could then go on to argue micronutrients along the same lines, with poop and pee more likely to contain those things, since aminals also are eurkaryotes so probably depend on some of the same


Indeed, but high intensity agriculture at a scale to feed earth's population consumes more nitrogen than can be obtained through crop rotation.


Farming basically never replenishes soil unless youre very carefully rotating mixed crops and animals through the area.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: