Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

SpaceX itself replicated the DC-X from the 90's. The reason the DC-X was cancelled was because of the economics. Reusable rockets are a solved problem, with only the economics of it a barrier (see Space Shuttle). SpaceX has to rely on their own investor funding for Starlink to remain a viable entity.


The DC-X was stupid, dumb, insane, bunkers, and a waste of money and not replicable.

"sure, let's put four RL-10 hydrogen engines on it! They are expensive and the worst possible for the low-altitude flights we are going to do so some sucker will believe we can do multi-stage reusable flights to orbit".

"sure, we don't actually need to go to orbit anyway. That was always a dumb idea. Who said we ever wanted to do that? No, suborbital is really useful, we promise. And we are going to do it with a single stage (using hydrogen) cuz we are so smart and the future and everything!"

"sure, let's build a specialized hydrogen tank in a stupid shape."

"sure, let's give the whole single-stage low-altitude rocket a k00l shape that makes it more expensive."

"People knowing it can't be done shouldn't interrupt people doing it wrong."




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: