No right to be free from what? If you are by yourself, who is there to enslave you? It doesn't matter how how rights are endowed; the entire concept is meaningless except with regard to other humans.

You have a right to be free from somebody trying to kill you. You do not have a right to force him to do your bidding.

Both of those rights govern exactly what I said: your interactions with other people. But anyway, no one is proposing anyone be forced to do someone's bidding.

> no one is proposing anyone be forced to do someone's bidding.

The proposed right to health care does exactly that.

That is not correct.

You and Bob are on a desert island. You have a right to health care. How are you going to make Bob give you health care?

You and Bob are on a desert island, and Bob is trying to kill you. You have a right to be free of someone trying to kill you. Bob is trying to kill you. How are you going to make him stop?

You have a right to defend yourself. You do not have a right to take from others. The two are not the same at all.