Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I just assume that there's a recording of me, at pretty much all times. I have always acted as if I was under scrutiny, anyway, so it's not been that big a deal, but it is annoying, to have it as a fact of life; as opposed to a personal choice for living.

Even when people are doing stuff like browsing pr0n, there's likely to be someone paying attention. Maybe not like those silly spam emails, but they know that we watched dwarf pr0n.





> just assume that there's a recording of me, at pretty much all times. I have always acted as if I was under scrutiny

Have you ever taken any civic action?


I assume you mean like demonstrations and whatnot. Not especially. I tend to roll up my sleeves and work in the shade.

I'm not saying it's a good thing. I'm just saying it's a thing; no matter what we think of it.


> assume you mean like demonstrations and whatnot

Not necessarily. Broadly. Advocacy, petitioning, calling, electioneering, drafting, lobbying, organising, et cetera.

A civically inactive citizenry frankly doesn’t have that much to lose from surveillance. Someone failing to exercise their political rights (EDIT: leaving them unexercised) pretty clearly communicates the value they place in them.


> Someone failing to exercise their political rights

I see what you did, there...

I tend to get a lot done. Not really into the whole "sound and fury" thing. I like to actually have results.


> see what you did, there

Genuinely asked if you’re politically engaged because I’m curious how that squares with your views on this topic?

Most Americans are not civically engaged. That’s sort of expected. Their principal opposition to surveillance revolves around being creeped out. Most folks who are civically engaged, on the other hand, recognise the risks to themselves and their projects if the opposition can command these tools. (As well as the power that would come with commanding them oneself.) If that link is no longer true, or not universally valid, I’m genuinely interested in hearing it. Because that implies independent civic action can survive—or potentially even thrive in—a modern surveillance state.


Seems a lot more an indictment. Maybe you might consider phrasing it differently.

I'm a recovering drug addict. I have quite an appreciation for privacy and anonymity. I have a lot more skin in the game than most.

However, there's the fantasy world in our heads, and the reality of the truth. These don't always overlap.

It's my job to work with yucchy reality. It doesn't give a damn what I think it should be. It's my responsibility to modify my approach to be most effective, given the context.

"When the map and the terrain disagree; believe the terrain." - Swiss Army aphorism




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: