Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> DC has a lower risk of shock than AC, because it still usually can't drive enough current through your skin to kill you

What? Common wisdom is that DC shock risk is worse than AC, as DC makes your muscles clench up and so it's harder to let go of whatever you grabbed. That "120Vac" is actually 170V peak though, which does increase shock risk for equivalent power transferred (maybe this is what you meant?).



No, AC also makes your muscles clench up, and it's even worse. At a given RMS voltage, AC is both more painful and more dangerous as a source of shocks. Edison was kind of right about that.

It's complicated, though. If you're running a low-level current through your body for a long time, like in the neighborhood of a milliamp, DC is much worse because it migrates your electrolytes around. And if you're using metal electrodes it might be migrating the metal from the anode into your body. So TENS units are strictly AC, with no DC bias permitted.


I'm still trying to understand if you're saying AC itself has a greater shock risk, or if you're merely commenting on peak vs RMS. For safety terms I personally think of AC voltages as their peak voltage, because I consider it a bit ridiculous to model myself as a resistive load being heated - meaning I consider my house wiring here in the US as being 170V. And I would consider (a stiff source of) 170V DC more dangerous in all respects, but perhaps I am wrong?

You may be right that the higher peaks are the reason sinewave 120Vac RMS is a heftier shock risk. Or it might also be the fact of being AC, in the sense that a square wave inverter output with 120V peak and RMS voltage maybe is more dangerous than 120Vdc. I don't know if it is or not. I could make up reasons that it might be, like maybe it's harder for neurons to adapt to, or maybe electrolyte depletion near the electrodes increases the body's resistance, but I don't have any evidence.

There really are some shock risks that result from your body being heated as a resistive load, like internal burns, but those are not at the top of the list, especially at only 120Vac.


IIUC AC current causes your muscles to twitch. This means that can cause you to be unable to let go of e.g. a live wire, fall off a ladder, or disrupt your heartbeat.

DC can do that too.



Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: