Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Maybe.

But having 10%+ of all Americans panicking after missing a few meals is also enough to topple a country. There’s not a whole lot that can unify the different political factions of the US, but going hungry gets people focused on necessity and to deprioritize the shallow / vapid aspects of politics.

Arguably it’s China’s governing body’s biggest single fear.

I currently think this government shutdown is unlikely to do that to the US because politicians have had lots of practice making each shutdown less impactful for most Americans, but the longer we go, the more likely we are to find some high value thing the US government does that Americans don’t want to live without.





I can't see any rational politician letting this go beyond another two weeks. I can't imagine keeping people away from their families over Thanksgiving is gonna work out well for anyone.

But then, maybe they're not rational.


I argue that politicians are absolutely rational. I frequently argue that even the dictator of N Korea acts rationally, only by very different rules than we are used to thinking about. Generally I reserve “irrational” to people who are functionally/mentally disabled, severely traumatized, or acting under the influence of mind altering substances (eg. RFK’s drugs history + trauma of 2 men in his life being assassinated during his formative years).

They are acting according to the expected responses to the stimuli they create. The problem is that the culture, society, previous legislation/jurisprudence, and the parliamentary rules they voted in all make the calculus of predicting what is rational for them uncertain.


> Arguably it’s China’s governing body’s biggest single fear.

Why China's? What you said is true in any corner of the globe.


China is the world’s most populous country with an autonomous governing body that doesn’t always respond to the voice of the people. And their leadership knows that multiple previous Chinese governments were toppled after the people were famished.

> Chinese governments were toppled after the people were famished

In imperial china it's a cultural/religious thing.

Famines always represented a sign that the ruling party wasn't wanted "by the skies" anymore.

In any case, ain't nobody ever gonna starve in modern china.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: