That's an interesting view. Thanks for posting it.
I would agree with this, if it wasn't for the aforementioned shady tactics...
Taking your needle program analogy, it would be extremely unethical if the needle program was paid for by the dealers and they used that opportunity to sell you more drugs, chat with you to find out if you're thinking of quitting, and offer you some free heroin if you are.
Similarly, short-term loan shops often employ strong-arm tactics to ensure they do receive payment. I.e., if you don't pay back, they'll send a couple of burly men to stand in your doorway until you do (as far as I know there's no evidence of them actually using violence, but the message is fairly clear).
So, to me, it seems payday loan shops are closer to the mafia/drug dealer side of things than to the needle program side.
I understand that to mean "increase regulation of payday loan companies" rather than "outlaw payday loan companies", on the grounds that unregulated outlaws are still a worse option.
However, regulating these companies to death puts you right back at the start again...
I would agree with this, if it wasn't for the aforementioned shady tactics...
Taking your needle program analogy, it would be extremely unethical if the needle program was paid for by the dealers and they used that opportunity to sell you more drugs, chat with you to find out if you're thinking of quitting, and offer you some free heroin if you are.
Similarly, short-term loan shops often employ strong-arm tactics to ensure they do receive payment. I.e., if you don't pay back, they'll send a couple of burly men to stand in your doorway until you do (as far as I know there's no evidence of them actually using violence, but the message is fairly clear).
So, to me, it seems payday loan shops are closer to the mafia/drug dealer side of things than to the needle program side.