Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So VR helmets, EW antennas embedded in stealth skin, and crazy combat networking are all trivial features that we should expect a gaggle of government contractors to get right on the first pass? I'm not sure I buy that argument. The plane looks plenty fancy to me, at least in the context of its alternatives ("first lol" tech demonstrators don't count).


Both the B-2 and F-22 have embedded antennas. JshWright's point seems to make sense: the complexity comes from system's integration and software, compounded by the aircraft having to be too many things to too many people.

Basically, software, of which there's a ton to say regarding F-35 development. All the features required and component integration required them to adopt an agile methodology, moving away from the Ada-style development processes and, arguably hacking things together until they kinda worked. The predictable result is a long-tail of bugs that may never be fully eradicated.


What's with the "embedded antennas" references?

Microstrips have been used in planes for decades.


I think the point is "embedded in stealth skin".


> "VR helmets,"

AR, not VR, right? Pretty sure they were doing that in helicopters years ago. Doesn't the Apache have a 30mm autocannon slaved to the pilot's helmet display, such that it shoots where the pilot looks? I'm no helmet geek, but I think that stuff came out in the 80s.

I suppose the F-35's implementation is cooler, on account of being newer, but it doesn't seem earth shattering to me.


> AR, not VR, right?

Probably depends, but the way I see it, AR is when you pass the world through but draw stuff on top of it, whereas VR means replacing what you see wholesale. So for instance, a HUD is AR, and F-35 helmet is VR.


> Apache have a 30mm autocannon slaved to the pilot's helmet display, such that it shoots where the pilot looks

The same system also exists for the Eurocopter Tiger


Sure, they are both ar. But one is about as nice as a virtual boy, while the f35 is an occulous. Huge differince in tech.


You've lost me at 'crazy combat networking'.

But next time I talk to my CEO I will try this with 'we do some crazy networking'.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: