Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Greece?





Argentina.

Ahaha I'm pretty sure he meant that it was Greece and not Italy that invented everything first.

Ah, I thought he was referring to the clowns they have in Athens.

But, no. The Greeks didn't create Western Civilization because the only non-awkward definition of Western Civilization is that scion of the Roman Church.

Surely the cultural exchange with Greeks contributed to this.

Greece was always eastern facing as far back as before Alexander. It is only with the Cold War that they glanced West.

Aside for Magna Grecia, Greeks have very scant presence in Western Europe.


I don't know why you are angry at history and frankly I don't care, but you should read a bit more. Even the Roman pantheon was practically a copy of the Greek one, Greek was the language of science and philosophy, the first people to study mathematics in the west and so on and so forth.

All the great Romans revered Greece and Greek.

Anyway I don't know why I'm explaining history to some random angry kid online, have a nice day


Yes, Athens is a part of the West. I never denied that. But how about Jerusalem? How about Rome? How about uncivilized (ie without a city) barbarians?

How about the over 1600 years of history since the split of the Roman empire?

The 1000 years since the Schism?

The 500 years since the Fall of Constantinople?

The Eastern Roman Empire was of a completely different character than the Western one, follows a vastly different path, and one that started diverging (due to all the heresies [0]) as early as Constantine. Since the fall of Constantinople the Greeks had very limited contact with the West until independence in the late 19th century.

According to you the West didn't do anything, didn't evolve, in the last 1600 years since we've been de facto incommunicado?

For example, to say that the West of the Scholastics is "Greek" when the Greeks have always rejected them (with very poignant criticism might I add) is a laugh in the face of the Scholastic's transformational contribution to the West (above all our modern university system).

St Augustine [1] , Boetius [2], and the Papacy [3] create the West anew from of these ingredients.

[0] which (Russian Orthodox) Solovyev lays at the feet of a jealous Greek hierarchy [1] accepted but looked down on by the Greeks [2] the last of the ancients and the first of the Scholastics [3] the most foundational institution for the West and rejected by the Greeks


You are conflating different and irrelevant arguments. The discussion was never about Byzantium or modern Greece. It was whether we can trace the beginning of Western civilisation in Ancient Greece instead of Rome, which indeed we can. Far before Christianity, a topic which you seem blindly passionate about, with some apparent beef against Orthodoxy.

This has little to do with Christianity.

And I find little interest in this pointless discussion, therefore this is my last reply.


If we're tracing seeds, the Ancient Greeks openly acknowledged their debt to Egypt. Therefore the Egyptians invented the West.

But my point is that the West is Rome enlightened by Greeks and humanized by Jews.

What is Athens + Jerusalem? Eastern Europe. Orthodoxy. (No beef, btw. Ive been to Meteora and just missed a chance to stay in Mt. Athos)

What is Rome + Athens + Jerusalem? The Catholic Church.


Your perception of history is muddled by religion.



Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: